I watched a PBS special Sunday called Trading Democracy hosted by Bill Moyers. (I need to watch PBS more often!) [transcript and clips]
Did you know that NAFTA basically made it possible for multinational companies to sue our government when they don't like our laws? Or at least that's how international lawyers are interpreting it.
The scariest example involves drinking water in California. When the state government realized that a gasoline additive and a proven carcinogen (MTBE) was getting into drinking water, they passed laws to phase out the additive. But then the Canadian company (Methanex) that makes the additive filed a claim arguing that California should cancel the restrictions -- or pay the company $970 million of taxpayer dollars. So in effect, we could be hindered in passing any laws that aim to protect U.S. citizens, but that might happen to be a tough pill for a multinational company to swallow.
These kinds of cases are cropping up all over, but why are these companies allowed to file these claims? Because of Chapter 11 in the NAFTA text. That chapter lets companies sue the government when they feel the government is causing them to lose money. And the chapter lays out some ground rules for the claims -- a closed tribunal where only the government lawyers and the company can attend. The general public rarely knows when these tribunals happen, and the public certainly is not allowed to voice their concern in the claims.
Why the hell is a non-American company allowed to bully us into the laws that they want, not what's best for our citizens? (Let alone why American companies are currently allowed to do that, but that's another issue entirely.)
And to top this all off, good ol' Bushie boy is currently negotiating a similar agreement with even more corporate privileges with 31 other countries. This agreement is called the Free Trade Area of the America (FTAA), and when the Senate votes on Bush's "fast-track" authority, they'll be voting on whether Bush can single-handedly and secretly negotiate our participation in this and other agreements. When "fast-track" comes up for a vote in the Senate, please remember these implications, and contact your Senators and ask them to vote no on "fast-track". Companies pushing for this Chapter 11-type provision in FTAA include GE, Ford, GM, International Paper, Motorola, Dow, DuPont, Chevron, Procter & Gamble, and 3M. UPS is currently in the process of filing a claim against the Canadian government because the Canadian parcel delivery service is "taking business away" from UPS. If you're the letter-writing type, I would certainly write a letter to each of these companies expressing your disapproval of their involvement and that you won't be buying their products. Web feedback forms are fine, but snail-mail letters (or phone calls) are even better:
GE: web form, email Gary Sheffer, GE contact for Public Affairs, Corporate, Environmental, Government, Labor Issues or call him at (203) 373-3476, or write to General Electric, 3135 Easton Turnpike, Fairfield, CT 06431
Ford: email, call at (800) 392-3673, or write to Ford Motor Company, Customer Relationship Center, P.O. Box 6248, Dearborn, MI 48126
GM: web form, call at (313) 556-5000, or write to General Motors Corporation, 300 Renaissance Center, P.O. Box 300, Detroit, Michigan 48265-3000
International Paper: email or write to International Paper, 400 Atlantic Street, Stamford, CT 06921
Motorola: web form, email Jennifer Weyrauch, Motorola contact for Public Affairs, call her at (847) 435-5320, or fax to (847) 576 7653, or write to Motorola, 1303 E. Algonquin Road, Schaumburg, IL 60196
Dow: web form, call (800) 258-2436, or write to Dow Chemical Company, 2030 Dow Center, Midland, MI 48674
DuPont: email, call (800) 441-7515, or write to DuPont Building, 1007 Market Street, Wilmington, DE 19898
Chevron: email, call (415) 894-7700, or write to ChevronTexaco Corporation, 575 Market Street, San Francisco, CA 94105
Procter & Gamble: web form, call (513) 983-1100, or write to Procter & Gamble, One Procter & Gamble Plaza, Cincinnati, OH 45202
3M: web form, email, call (888) 364-3577, or write to 3M, 3M Center, St. Paul, MN 55144
UPS: web form, call (404) 828-6000, or write to United Parcel Service, Inc., 55 Glenlake Parkway, NE, Atlanta, GA 30328
Try to catch the Trading Democracy special the next time it's on PBS (click TV Schedules).